Bruiser Brody v Jose Gonzalez
This story is truly controversial. Rumor has it that during a show in 1988 in Puerto Rico, Jose stabbed Bruiser to death inside the showers. It is alleged that wrestlers in Puerto Rico didn’t like Brody (an American wrestler) because he was making so much money in their country.
Later, Jose would plead guilty for murder only for the case to take a twist and be deemed as self-defense. To date, wrestling enthusiasts remain shocked that no further investigation took place. In fact, most people termed the entire situation a cover up.